Skip to content
  • About
  • Intellectual Property
  • Our Services
    • Patents
    • Trademarks
    • Copyrights
    • Designs
    • Geographical Indications
    • Cyber Law
    • IP Health Index
  • Puthrans Logo Puthrans Logo Puthrans Logo
  • IP Unplugged
  • Careers
  • Contact Us

When Phonetic Similarity Is Not Enough: The Telangana High Court on Composite Marks and Consumer Awareness

Home|Featured, IP Unplugged|When Phonetic Similarity Is Not Enough: The Telangana High Court on Composite Marks and Consumer Awareness
Previous Next
When Phonetic Similarity Is Not Enough: The Telangana High Court on Composite Marks and Consumer Awareness

The Telangana High Court recently clarified that no business can monopolise the use of common geographical terms and names of deities in trademarks. The Division Bench upheld the order of the Trial Court in the case of M/s Sai Silks (Kalamandir) Limited vs. SKP B Gopinath Private Limited, holding that “phonetic similarities between the two marks would pale into insignificance in the context of a visual comparison of the rival trademarks.”

The said judgment dismissed the appeal filed by the Plaintiff, M/S Sai Silks (Kalamandir) Limited, the proprietors of the mark “Kancheepuram Vara Mahalakshmi Silks” and its variants. The Appeal was filed against the order of the City Civil Court of Hyderabad dismissing the Plaintiff’s two interlocutory applications in a suit for trademark infringement and permanent infringement.  The said interlocutory applications were filed for the appointment of a Local Commissioner to visit the premises of M/s. Kanchipuram Varahi Lakshmi Silks and seize the infringing materials bearing the mark “Kanchipuram Varahi Lakshmi Silks” and for an ex parte ad interim injunction restraining the Defendants from using, selling, or stocking goods under the mark “Kanchipuram Varahi Lakshmi Silks” or any mark deceptively similar to the registered marks: “Kancheepuram Vara Mahalakshmi Silks,” “Vara Mahalakshmi Silks Kancheepuram,” and “Vara Mahalakshmi.” The Trial Court was of the view that the competing marks Kancheepuram Vara Mahalakshmi Silks and Kanchipuram Varahi Lakshmi Silks had “striking dissimilarities” that outweighed the phonetic similarities of the competing marks and that the Defendant’s usage of the geographical origin cannot be considered as a copy of the Plaintiff’s mark, as the core features are different.

Pursuant to filing the appeal before the Hon’ble Division Bench, the Court observed that for actions of passing off and infringement, the Plaintiff must satisfy the troika of prima facie case, irreparable injury and balance of convenience.  Further, the Plaintiff must also establish the following classical trinity to prove passing off:

  • The reputation of the Plaintiff’s mark
  • Misrepresentation with regard to the origin of the mark
  • Consequential damage to the Plaintiff as a result of the action complained of. [1]

Considering the above, while comparing the marks-  and , the Court found that the Plaintiff’s mark is in the form of a label and comprises words such as “Kancheepuram”, “Vara Mahalakshmi” and “Silks” which are common and non-distinctive with regard to the saree trade. Accordingly, the Court broke down the trade marks as follows:

  • “Kancheepuram” is a city in Tamil Nadu that is known for silk sarees, and Kanjeevaram Sari, traditionally woven in the city, has been recognised as a Geographical Indication in 2006.
  • “Vara Mahalakshmi” refers to Goddess Lakshmi and is commonly used in trade names, and “Varahi Lakshmi” is the boar-faced manifestation of Goddess Lakshmi
  • “Silks” is generic for the saree business.

Therefore, the Plaintiff/ Appellant cannot claim that the above words are distinctive of their sarees or have become exclusively associated with them. It was observed that the mark does not contain any single dominant or essential feature which is distinctive of the Appellant. The Court concluded that the Plaintiff’s mark is a composite label mark which attracts Section 17 of the Trademarks Act, and according to Section 17(2)(b) of the Act, they cannot claim exclusive rights over the component parts of a mark that are common to trade or non-distinctive.

It is also crucial to note that the Court reframed the consumer confusion test. It observed that a saree purchase involves tactile evaluation and that in the age of print/digital/social media, the customers are more informed and brand aware. Hence, the test of a person with ‘average intelligence and imperfect recollection’ traditionally applied by Indian courts would not be suitable in the present case.

It was thus concluded that the phonetic similarity of the two trademarks cannot be treated as a sole determining factor given the fact that the Plaintiff’s mark did not contain any distinctive or unique element to claim exclusive rights. Therefore, the statutory rights are extended to the marks as a whole according to Section 17(1) of the Act and not over the non-distinctive components. On this basis, the claim of passing off based on the classic trinity also fell short. Accordingly, the appeal was dismissed.

The finding of the Hon’ble Telangana High Court that the Plaintiff has not copied the distinctive features of the Plaintiff’s mark is interesting, as there is a fine line between phonetic similarity and deceptive similarity leading to confusion and deception. By usual practice, the phonetic similarity is given greater importance, especially where the competing marks share several similar sounding elements. The Court’s refusal to apply the traditional “average consumer with imperfect recollection” test is particularly significant as it indicates that consumer sophistication has evolved over the years and purchasers are more brand-aware due to the modern-day influence of digital and social media. This reduces the likelihood of confusion, which cannot be presumed merely on the basis of phonetic similarity between two trademarks.

Written by
Shwetha S Menon
Disclaimer: This post is for general informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute formal legal advice. The featured image is an AI-generated illustration.
By puthrans|2026-10-05T05:24:47+00:00October 5th, 2026|Featured, IP Unplugged|0 Comments

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

facebooktwitterlinkedinredditwhatsapptumblrpinterestvkEmail

About the Author: puthrans

© Copyright - | Puthran & Associates | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy
facebook